‘Tis the season to sell “choose and cut Christmas trees.” This time of year, between Thanksgiving and Christmas is when “choose and cut” Christmas tree growers sell to the public. The farm is alive with families combing the hillside to find that special tree to take home and decorate.
About 35 years ago while living in suburbia, my next-door neighbor suggested we buy a piece of land and grow Christmas trees. His line of reason went something like this. “We plant the trees and come back in 10 years and sell them all.” We didn’t pursue his idea.
Little did I imagine that a few decades later I would be doing exactly that. Well not exactly. In 2001 I bought a 31-acre farm in south/central Pennsylvania. That is rated climate zone 4. The arable land was leased out to two local farmers who grew corn, wheat and soy beans and I decided to keep the arrangement in place to help with the taxes.
There were a couple of acres though that were too steep to farm so I started to explore how I could put it to use. I contacted the county extension service and they came up with several suggestions such as an orchard, berry or flower growing or Christmas trees. Since I was still working full time and having an 80-mile round trip commute to my workplace, I opted for Christmas trees since it seemed to me be the least time-consuming.
My farm lane is long and narrow and not user friendly for large trucks which would be required for a wholesale operation so I elected to opt for the “choose and cut” option. I researched what species to plant, orientation, spacing, soil pH, etc. The hillside I planned to utilize faced south, not the optimum direction according to the information I found but I decided to give it a shot. I explained to my wife, “Even if we don’t sell any trees, we will have planted a forest.”
The recommended spacing for planting is five feet between trees and six feet between rows. If you are planning on wholesaling you will need to leave space at intervals to allow for loading the cut trees on trucks. This means you can plant approximately 1,455 trees on an acre of ground. Based upon the acreage available and the time and labor you can invest the size of the operation is up to you. The ability to size the operation to fit your space and time available is a great advantage. You may also find that you are able to accomplish the shearing and harvesting during times of the year when you would not normally be too busy with other chores.
In 2003 in order to see which varieties would do best, I ordered 600 three-year seedlings: one hundred each of Fraser Fir, Douglas Fir, Norway Spruce, Black Hills Spruce, Colorado Blue Spruce, and Scotch Pine. I would later add Concolor Firs. Costs ran about 50 cents per seedling including shipping. The dry root seedlings arrived in mid-April and my wife and I planted them using a digging bar. Things went well in April and May but we began to lose seedlings in June when the weather turned dry. Because of time constraints and the plantings being located uphill from a water source, irrigation was not an option. Perhaps survivability rates would have been higher if I had used an auger to create some loose soil around the seedling rather than compacting the soil with the digging bar. I would switch over to a gas power auger in later years.
Based on the results of my first year’s planting I decided to concentrate on Fraser and Douglas Firs due to their superior survivability rate versus the other species.
Over the next eight years I planted 500 seedlings per year. The first few years all I had to do was plant. As the trees began to grow, I had to go through the planting and snip off a stray shoot or two. Then the faster growing Scotch Pines needed shearing. This is done anytime after new growth is established usually by the end of June. Because of the high mortality rate, I never had more than a thousand trees to shear at one time, but it would still take a couple of weeks to complete the job. I used a gas-powered hedge trimmer, later switching to a battery-powered one. This was very labor-intensive having to rake up and dispose of the clippings. Mowing was also a chore particularly during wet seasons. Other problems started to occur. Despite still losing trees to drought at the top of the hill, I lost trees in low lying areas due to root rot. Pests like bagworms were a minor nuisance.
Then disaster struck. Just as my Douglas firs were getting to the marketable height of 5 to 6 feet, they became infested with a fungus known as Swiss Needle Cast. As the name implies it causes the needles of the tree to fall. A grower nearby, who had become my mentor sprayed the trees with a fungicide but I was not happy with the results. He informed me that the trees would have to be sprayed 4 to 5 times a year. After calculating the cost of the spray and the labor involved, I decided to cut down the trees and burn them. Potential loss: 300 trees at $40 each = $12,000. My accountant informed me that I could only claim the actual cost of the tree which was the original cost of 50 cents and any other cost associated with growing them. Since I was doing all the labor myself, any additional expenses were negligible. The most disappointing aspect of the whole affair was having to remove the trees I worked so hard to raise.
I had originally estimated that it would take around 6 to 8 years to grow the trees to a marketable height. Since I did not fertilize and was now relying on the slower-growing Fraser Firs, I had to stretch out my timeline. I did manage to sell some Scotch Pines, Douglas Firs and Colorado Blue Spruce to friends and family early on but it wasn’t until 3 years ago that I was able to sell to the general public. That’s 15 years! I believe my biggest mistake was planting 3- year seedlings instead of 5-year transplants. This might improve the mortality rate and shorten the time to marketability. On the other hand, they cost more and I would need to purchase some equipment to make a larger hole while planting to accommodate the larger roots.
The Scotch pines grew quickly and I was able to sell them within the first couple of years. Once they reached a certain height they become unshapely and difficult to prune. A good choice to grow while the slower growing trees mature.
The Norway spruce also grew fairly quickly and grow full and thick which customers like. On the other hand, the needles are stiff and a bit prickly. They tend to grow in a stout shape which needs heavy shearing.
The other spruces have the same characteristics as the Norway spruce.
The Douglas fir grow fairly quickly but unless your area is free of Swiss needle cast disease or you are willing to spray, I do not recommend planting them.
The Concolor firs grow relatively fast. They have a unique citrus smell and soft needles. A nice niche market.
One thing that worked out in my favor was selecting Fraser Firs. They are quite popular with the buying public and because they take longer to grow few people bother to plant them. The needles are soft yet the branches are strong enough to support ornaments.
So, was it worth it? If I tried to calculate my pay, I’m sure it would be in the cents per hour range. One thing that I forgot to take into account is that deer hunting season coincides with Christmas tree sales time. Did I mention that whitetail bucks love to rub their antlers on conifers? I do manage to go out and hunt early in the mornings for a couple of hours before I open up for business. Another nice facet of the operation is the fact that I can do other chores while waiting for customers to arrive. We are usually not too busy during the week and I use that time to do things like performing seasonal maintenance on my lawnmowers and other equipment. At 68 years of age I am pretty well done in by the end of the day.
One major benefit that I really didn’t consider when starting out is making contacts in the community. Folks like to comment on the quality of the trees, the deer rubs, hunting, the country setting and, yes, politics. I can sort out the like-minded folks from the herd.
The other day talking hunting with a repeat customer, he mentioned he could not find any .270 Winchester ammo for his hunting rifle. Since I stocked up years ago, I sold him 20 rounds at cost. Since it was the day before the season opener, he was certainly appreciative.
It fills my heart with joy to see the families come out and share the experience together: grandparents, mothers and fathers with their children, newlywed couples just starting out, older couples. Yeah, it’s worth it.
Thanks for sharing your experience with Christmas tree farming! Many years ago, I read a middle-grade age book about a girl who finds an orphaned wolf puppy in the middle of her family’s Christmas tree farm in the great northwest (Montana?) and HOW MUCH WORK it was as they had to go out and prune all those trees, and then harvest, bag, and ship them to the cities for barely pennies. If anybody remembers the name of that book, speak up! I’d like to get it for my kids.
We have people who grow trees around here to sell to the landscapers and home centers, but not many Christmas tree farms unless you take a very long drive.
Is this the book you’re looking for?
Chestnut (American Dog series)
https://www.amazon.com/Chestnut-American-Dog-Jennifer-Shotz/dp/0358108748
Alas, no… not the book. But it looks like a kind of awesome book, so I just ordered it for my grandson 🙂 Thanks!
One more try… i think this might be it based on the comments.
My Wolf, My Friend
by Barbara Corcoran
Original Title – Sasha, My Friend
https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/1261270.My_Wolf_My_Friend
Yes!!! That’s it! Thank you … couldn’t remember the name and couldn’t find it.
Gonna order a copy for my kids to read. The girl lives on a Christmas tree farm in Montana, homeschools, and finds an orphaned wolf pup.
I had a Christmas tree farm in Vermont, I would plant around 2500 trees per year. I did not have the high mortality that the writer did, mainly because of Vermont’s rain fall. He is right about becoming friends with the people that came to cut trees. I haven’t sold a tree in 10 years but I’m still known as the Christmas tree man. I use to have hot cider available for free for customers, I could go through 20 gallons a weekend. People ask me why I don’t still do it, 1: I’m currently 65, this is a physically demanding job. 2: Its real nice to get a lot of cash in a few weeks but if you figure out your pay per hour of work, you’d be better off working at McDonalds.
One of the shortcomings of globalization not mentioned by the urban News Media is the frequent importation of destructive pests. Gypsy moth. Ash trees being destroyed by Emerald Ash borer. etc
A new imported pest making its way across Pennsylvania is the Spotted Lantern Fly — a significant threat to fruit trees, grape vineyards, and Christmas trees. If you have any Tree of Heaven trees on your property it might help to destroy them. Although that requires Roundup on the root system and some environmental groups are trying to get Roundup banned.
https://extension.psu.edu/spotted-lanternfly
This report estimates the economic damage to various Pennsylvania agricultural and forestry products from the spread of the fly — page 16 notes the harm to Christmas Tree crops.
https://www.rural.palegislature.us/documents/reports/Spotted-Lanternfly-2019.pdf
It also estimates the costs to the landowners of trying to suppress /control the fly. If your county comes under quarantine, you will have to get a special permit in order to sell the trees– as noted in the first link above.
Try using Triclopyr-4 instead of Roundup. I used it on a very thick (inches apart) stand of arelia trees. They can tolerate a huge amount of damage, and their vicious little thorny selves bounce right back, thicker than ever. They spread through roots, and tens of thousands of seeds apiece.
The Triclopyr-4 killed them very permanently dead. Triclopyr-4 is about as non-toxic as a weed and tree killer can be. It disintegrates in about an hour.
You should mix it with an oil to get it to stick. The only real drawback is the hideously expensive price, but it is cheaper than getting cancer.
My next door neighbor used Roundup on an arelia infested part of her property. The next year, two of my outdoor cats died of cancer. It was pathetic; they were too feral to help. I had had an outdoor colony for eight years, and all of the cats were perfectly healthy before that.
so they´d globalisation in antiquity or was it the stone age?
PS My wife and I have been buying Christmas trees from a local farm for 25 years — one of our favorite Christmas traditions. In part because it’s nice to walk across the fields and choose the tree. Plus the farmer has a haywagon pulled by a tractor that periodically comes around and carries us, our tree and other families back to the loading area. Where the farming family has hot apple cider.
It is also a favorite tradition because we did it with our son over the years as he grew up — we still remember the fun he had as a little guy.
Unfortunately, suburban development is surrounding the farm and I fear the Covid virus –another imported pest — will ruin this years Christmas revenue for the farm and make it hard to pay property taxes.
We have utilized “Cut your own” Christmas Tree farms since moving to our retreat home 8 years ago. We went out yesterday to find and cut our tree. For the first time ever, we came across multiple farms that had been forced to close early this year–but not for a lack of business, rather, because they sold out of trees. It seems the virus has encouraged more people to cut their own this year, and to do it earlier than ever. I never expected to see a shortage of Christmas trees, but that is exactly what we have here in N Ga. We were unable to find any trees in our normal 10′-12′ height, instead having to cut a 14’+ tree and take off the bottom. Hopefully those tree growers have taken in some higher than normal profits this year, too.
Anne,
I believe the book you are looking for is My Wolf, My Friend (also called Sasha, My Friend) by Barbara Corcoran. I read it as a kid and got it for my girls. Only one read most of it, and she quit when it got too sad. I don’t remember the Christmas tree farm. I don’t recall why the girl moved to Montana after her mother died, but the rest of it fits.
Angela
Thanks for sharing!
I’ve got some spare patches not doing much, and I’ve contemolated planting a small patch for “friends and family”.
I liked the article about raising the trees. This comment is about the upcoming Georgia senate elections. All conservative voters need to take a photo of their ballot
choices and then if the state republican party has a web site then email the photo to the website as a record of their vote. It would be evideince of their vote and also record the number of votes.
I live in the California Soviet Socialist Republic. I wish I had taken a picture of my ballot. All I can do now is to keep searching for jobs in the Redoubt or another red state.
I have considered Christmas tree farming on the limited acres available to me but the amount I could get from them due to the limited amount at any given harvest negated that idea. Drylands grain is the better option but requires more harvesting equip.
I do remember though, buying Christmas trees when a kid running about 5-10 bucks. Yeah, I am that old. Surprising I’m still here eh! But good on ya for even attempting to make a go at it. My hats off to ya.
Great article WW, thanks for sharing. I’ve often wondered what it would be like to operate a tree farm, sounds like a lot more work than I thought!
I remember when I was eight or nine my dad and neighbor planted 3-5 acres of saplings. They used some sort of tractor pulled machine. Low to the ground, it had a flat front section where the saplings laid, some sort of v-type plow center rear, and two angled rear tires behind that to push the dirt back around the trees. I don’t recall if the trees were fed automatically or hand dropped. Also I don’t recall anyone ever shaping the trees in the following years. Eight years later I got paid to set in my car and sell them. “Cut your own – $2.00”. Back then you didn’t need a perfect Christmas tree. Kids were more interested in what was under the tree than the tree itself. Just think of all the people today that probably think every pine tree looks like a perfectly shaped Christmas tree.
A friend of mine grew up with a Christmas tree farm. His parents bought it, the kids worked it, and the profits were saved and used to pay for the kids’ college educations. Three kids, a doctorate or two and master’s degrees. I think they had a modest 20 acres and I don’t have any other details. Good planning and the entrepreneurial spirit allowed them good educations without incurring overwhelming debt.