E-Mail 'Letters Re: My Family Preparedness Plan, by R.S.' To A Friend

4 Comments

1. I wish to comment on the “containment camps” statements. Anyone desiring to research FEMA can go to fema.gov and also go to gpo.gov and download Title 44 CFR to get in print exactly what FEMA is allowed to do according to law. The scare of being forced into a type of containment area by a government agency is not a concern for me as an informed law abiding prepper. Yes, “Old Hickory” did that despicable act around 1830 and many Japenese Americans near the west coast of the US were also victims of containment during WWII. I believe our policy makers have learned from those unfortunate actions and will not repeat them. I agree that FEMA pre positions items like bottled water, cots and MRE’s at potential storm sites for reasons already covered.
   But, I do not believe there are any sites anywhere in the US being considered for containment of law abiding citizens against their will. The Superdome was used as a shelter during the Hurricane Katrina disaster as authorized by the mayor of New Orleans and the governor of Louisiana. FEMA cannot provide any assistance to a state until asked by the governor of that state, by law, e.g. The Stafford Act, and 44 CFR and then only assistance as declared and approved by the president. Thus, any reference to the Superdome actions should be to the state
   of Louisiana and the city of New Orleans independently.

   1. @David,
      While FEMA cannot act until asked by the state, all states are eager for FEMA involvement. That’s the whole point of declaring an “emergency” – to open up the path to obtaining federal funds and manpower. There is no state in the union right now that wants to spend their own money (and only their own money) when they can obtain federal assistance. Additionally, to my knowledge, there is no state that is adequately equipped to handle large scale disasters. Katrina, Sandy and others have shown how easily states get in over their heads. Even the Ferguson riots ended up with federal help. What we learn is that the states are eager to involve the feds, if nothing else, for the funding.
      What our policy makers have learned is that while some people may scream and rant about the unconstitutionality of actions such as the Japanese internment camps and other atrocities, they can still act with impunity with virtually no fear of reprisals. Yes, there are rules against the things that were done (there have been rules against it from the beginning of the U.S.), but we also learn that if the government feels the need or desire to violate those rules, they can and will do so as they see fit. Does history ever show that anyone of significance was ever held accountable for their actions of such violations? Obama, Hillary, perhaps Bush, and others stand out as people who willingly lied and violated the constitution, but have they been held accountable? Have they even had a valid, untainted investigation into their actions?
      I would agree that forced detainment is unlikely, but there is precedent for just such an action on a pretty large scale during WWII.

      1. We only have to look at Katrina to realize we have nothing to fear from FEMA on a large scale event!!!!

2. Hugh,

   I was part of the Army contingent that was located in the Superdome and as a born and raised resident of Louisiana with family located there, I volunteered to go in and help as I was intimately familiar with the preparations before impact. I can tell you the nightmares of riding a cat 3/4 Hurricane in the ‘Dome.

   However, as many other have stated that the Stafford Act prohibits FEMA interaction w/o due cause and proper legal (non martial law) occasions. With this said, curfew was implemented (if my memory serves) 3 days before and we got the call 3 hours before impact that Martial Law was in effect until otherwise ordered.

   I watched a disaster become a warzone within 12 hours of impact. I would rather have another tour in Iraq/Afghanistan than go back to new orleans.

Comments are closed.