Letter Re: Grey Water for Toilets


I have an idea to provide rain water for toilets when other water is not available. My thought is to place a small broad flatish tank (10 gallons or so) on the rafters in the attic above the bathroom. Then I would modify the vent through the roof to feed the tank and to still provide venting. When the tank is full, the rain would just flow over the “roof drain”. A sort of V shaped channel dam on the roof could divert additional water to the drain into the tank.

There are many possible ways to fill the toilet, ranging from a spicket just over the toilet tank to a dual valve arrangement keeping the water systems separated. Periodically the tank could be drained into the toilet to refresh the water in the tank. If the topic is interesting, I would like to know what the rest of the community thinks. – M.M.

HJL’s Comment: I doubt such an arrangement would make it past the building inspectors approval, but here are some of my thoughts:

  1. The rafters are generally not designed to carry concentrated weight unless purposely built. This limits the size of tank you can use.
  2. I have seen toilets that flush with only 1 liter of water, but I’ve never seen one that I liked. The 2.5 liter flushes start getting more to my liking. This means that a 10-gallon tank will give you, at most, 15 flushes. Is that enough?
  3. Plumbing designed to manage both systems will require backflow preventers and increase the cost.
Bookmark the permalink.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.
Anonymous comments are allowed, but will be moderated.
Note: Please read our discussion guidlelines before commenting.