Introduction
It’s every prepper’s fantasy: living in (mostly) a self-sufficient secure compound surrounded by liked-minded individuals living off the land just out of reach of the ravaging hordes. For novelists and daydreamers, living on the frontier in a simpler way is an appealing escape from the often-disheartening humdrum of ordinary life. Rather than worry about politics and taxes, you worry about raiders and if this summer’s crop will come in. But in the pages of fiction or the corners of our imagination, the good guy always prevails. Reality is much more stark.
Those who lived on Israeli kibbutzim—collective compound-style communities— probably felt quite secure until October 7, 2023. The Hamas attacks upon Israel should be enough to disabuse the prepared citizen from the romance of the SHTF compound fantasy. Those who are concerned about the United States degenerating into a situation where something similar is possible need to confront the awful reality of enemy raids on compounds as seen by the Israelis.
There are some differences, of course, to the collapse that preppers imagine. Israel is, and was, a functional country with operating police and military; however, they failed to prevent the incursion and were not able to come to the immediate aid of the kibbutz residents. Yet in other respects the Hamas militants shared many characteristics of post-apocalyptic raiders: they were well armed, coordinated, semi-disciplined, and after striking in force, took control of the compounds and murdered, kidnapped, or abused the residents. The only distinction between Israel and the fantastic is Hamas didn’t intend to capture and hold the compounds for themselves, as an SHTF villain might.Continue reading“Retreat Security: What We Can Learn from Israel – Part 1, by Don Shift”